What Happened to The Promise of An Affordable New York?

18
Nov
2026
 
What Happened to The Promise of An Affordable New York?
Surveillance Pricing Bills will Cost Virtually Every Single New York Family Money 
Hochul and Mamdani Must Veto the Bills 
 
ALBANY, NY - The Business Council of New York State (BCNYS) has a warning for New Yorkers: the surveillance pricing bills will cost virtually every single New York family money.
At a time when New Yorkers are struggling with the rising cost of groceries, food, clothing and everyday necessities, New Yorkers are calling on Governor Hochul and Mayor Mamdani to save popular consumer discounts and savings programs that millions of families rely on. See the recently released poll that shows support dropped significantly when New Yorkers learned they could lose discounts. CLICK HERE
Those discounts can be saved with vetoes from the Governor and the Mayor, and that’s why the BCNYS is starting a six-figure campaign to inform New Yorkers about these bills and their potential impact.
“To say that New Yorkers should be outraged about these bills is an understatement," said Paul Zuber, Executive Vice President at The Business Council of New York State. "These bills are so poorly written, so poorly vetted, and so poorly understood that most don’t understand that they will cause every single New York family to lose discounts that they rely on to save money - discounts that are available in every other state but will not be available in New York. The Business Council is starting a statewide campaign, so consumers understand what is about to happen to the very popular discounts that we all know and love."
The New York State Legislature passed the One Fair Price Act (S.8623-B/A.9349-B), while the New York City Council approved its own surveillance pricing legislation (Introduction 891-A). Both measures are designed to prevent businesses from using consumers' personal information to charge different prices for the same products. That part of the bill is commendable, but the legislation goes too far. Instead of simply prohibiting businesses from using personal data to charge consumers higher prices, the bills could also prevent companies from using that same information to offer consumers lower prices.
New Yorkers would lose access to discounts and personalized savings opportunities that consumers in every other state can continue to enjoy.
Among the everyday discounts that critics warn could disappear or become significantly restricted are:
  • Grocery discounts: Personalized coupons and loyalty offers that can save shoppers $20 to $50 per week on groceries.
  • Clothing and retail discounts: Special offers on clothing, shoes and household products based on what consumers have browsed, purchased or left in their online shopping carts.
  • Customer loyalty rewards: Special promotions and discounts offered to frequent shoppers and returning customers.
  • Restaurant and food delivery discounts: Personalized deals that help consumers save money on meals and delivery orders.
  • Hotel and travel discounts: Special rates and promotional offers based on customers' travel history or loyalty membership.
  • Internet, cable and subscription discounts: Promotional credits and reduced rates offered to customers who are considering canceling their service because of rising costs.
  • Birthday and special occasion promotions: Personalized savings offered to customers based on birthdays, anniversaries and other milestones.
The problem: while the bills contain exceptions for certain traditional sales, coupons and rewards programs, their restrictions on how businesses use customer information could prevent many of the personalized discounts consumers have come to depend on.
For example:
A grocery shopper who receives personalized weekly coupons based on their shopping habits would lose those savings. 
A consumer would not be able to get a discount from their local mom & pop restaurant.
A family struggling with an expensive cable or internet bill could find it harder to obtain an individualized promotional rate.
More information about the recently launched campaign can be found HERE.
###