|
The
Business Council is an Albany treasure. This is my first appearance
before your group, and you may not know me as well as I would
like. I hope and expect to change that. But be assured, by
your good works, I know you very well. You have been a great
friend to our Governor. A source of strength and wisdom. Your
advocacy on behalf of growth and prosperity has been essential
to all that we have accomplished in our great state, and we
are much indebted to you.
I
don't know how many of you had the opportunity to see the
Governor deliver the State of the State speech last week.
For those that did, I think I am in good company in saying
that it demonstrated once again, why we are so proud of Governor
Pataki, and why he was overwhelmingly re-elected to a third
term. Like you, he understands New York. Our greatness, but
also our challenges. He understands that high taxes and excessive
regulation have real consequences. That they cost jobs and
reduce people's income. Like you he understands the importance
of investing in new technology and remaining competitive.
One
of the most exciting portions of the Governor's speech concerned
our university-based Centers of Excellence. As you know, in
just two short years, these Centers have proven a remarkable
success. Already, they have attracted nearly $1 billion in
investment from the private sector and the federal government.
International SEMATECH is moving ahead with its $400 million
Research and Development initiative. Tokyo Electron Limited
has committed to build a $300 million R&D Center at the Albany
Center of Excellence in Nanoelectronics, which is now under
construction. Ground has been broken in Buffalo on the facility
for the Center of Excellence in BioInformatics.
In
greater Rochester, they are moving ahead with labs in a new
photonics facility.
In
Syracuse, site selection has begun for an environmental science
facility.
And
AMD, the chip maker, has committed to invest hundreds of millions
in partnership with IBM in the Hudson Valley. More good news
is expected soon on biotechnology in Greater New York City.
All
of these represent remarkable achievements and are testament
to Governor Pataki's vision and fiscal discipline, because
without our investments in higher education and without an
improving tax environment, these companies would not be coming
here. They are the future of New York's ongoing Renaissance.
The
fact is that there is no limit to what we can achieve in New
York, provided that we pursue the right policies. For my part,
I believe there are five key principles that should guide
us in formulating these policies and in creating the kind
of future that we as New Yorkers deserve.
The
first of these principles is freedom, economic and political,
because freedom is what creates prosperity, and freedom is
what allows people to change themselves and change the world
around them.
Closely
related to freedom is opportunity, which I see as the second,
key principle. Every person in our state, whatever their background,
must have the right to rise as far as his or her ability will
take them. We must eliminate all unfair barriers to achievement.
Economic
growth is the third, key principle. In a competitive world,
those who do not move forward, fall back. Government must
pursue pro-growth economic policies. There is no alternative.
A
fourth, key principle is quality of life. I am convinced that
much of what we have in life is what we share. We must keep
our streets safe. Parks and clean neighborhoods, an environment
to inspire us, all of these are essential.
And
lastly, educational excellence is a fifth, key principle.
We must continue to invest in education at all levels of our
society. As we do so, we also must demand accountability.
I am a firm believer in standards. If you set them high, people
will meet them. If you set them low, people will meet those
too. Excellence must be our educational North Star.
As
we think about these principles, allow me to emphasize the
one that I believe is most important, and that is freedom.
You know after 9/11, I was asked to speak at many functions.
In particular I spoke at several dozen funerals for firefighters.
In preparation for those remarks, I was forced to think a
lot about America and what makes us different. What struck
me, as I thought more and more about these matters, is how
incredibly important freedom is, and what it does for a person
and a nation.
I
was asked one time, along with Mayor Giuliani, to escort Nelson
Mandela to Ground Zero, and I will never forget what he said,
not about himself or his country, but what he said about us,
America. He said that on television, when he watched New Yorkers
respond immediately after the attack, he was amazed. What
he envied, he said, was not our economic might, or military
power, what he envied was our people, our tremendous ability
to work together.
Without
anyone telling anyone what to do, spontaneously, New Yorkers
from all walks of life immediately began to volunteer to help
each other. Off-duty nurses and doctors rushed to the nearest
hospital. Taxi drivers picked up those, who were injured.
Ordinary citizens streamed to emergency rooms and elsewhere
to donate blood. Others hurried to the West Side highway with
food and beverages. Upstate rushed to aid downstate. Suburbs
helped the City. Why? What explains that?
Well
I think there is an answer, and the answer has to do with
freedom. It might be called the Great Paradox of Freedom.
Rather than driving people apart or causing conflict, as those
who oppose freedom have always believed, I am convinced that
freedom actually impels people to help each other and to cooperate.
Why? The reason is that freedom creates in people self-reliance,
which in turn makes them more self-confident. And this is
key. Self-confident people are more likely to trust each other,
and therefore, they are also more likely to help each other.
They will cooperate, not because they are told to, but because
they want to. This is what economists and sociologists refer
to as social capital: the ability of people to work together
in pursuit of common goals. It is the Great Paradox of Freedom,
and as Americans, it is our Great Blessing!
Freedom
is also the reason that a vibrant business community is so
important to our social well-being. Nothing does more to create
self-reliance than running a business, meeting a payroll,
deciding whether to invest and how much. America's entrepreneurial
culture is more than anything else a reflection of American
freedom. Culture, economics and politics, all are built around
this basic belief in freedom. It's central to who we are,
and it's central to our future as a people. And that is why
I am so pleased to be here. Because what your group does is
seek to preserve and, unfortunately too often, recapture economic
freedom here in New York. I applaud you for that.
When
we think about business, we also must think about taxes. However
much we improve our schools or make our neighborhoods safe,
we will not be able to bring New York all the way back unless
we also confront the issue of taxes. There may have been a
time in the past, when taxes were less important than they
are today. Some regions of the country lacked adequate infrastructure.
In many states, public schools and universities were under
funded.
But
if taxes may have been less important in the past, no one
can seriously make that case today, although I realize that
some will continue to try. Other regions of the country have
clearly caught up. Computers and the Internet have changed
the way people do business. And capital has never been more
mobile. The growth of publicly traded companies, in tandem
with the shareholders rights movement, has also changed the
landscape of business. Nowadays, managers face more pressure
than ever to meet their numbers, maybe too much pressure.
So, yes, taxes matter. They clearly affect business location
decisions. And they clearly affect investment decisions.
As
the state's chief economist Steve Kagann points out, large
corporations think long and hard about where they want to
allocate their investment dollars. It makes headlines, when
a company decides to move into or out of a state, but over
the long term, investment decisions are just as important.
A company that can earn a higher after-tax rate of return
in one state rather than another is more likely to invest
in new plant and technology, where it can earn the most money.
That does not mean that company directors will immediately
shut down a factory, or close an office or processing center,
just because taxes are high. No, but decision making can change
rapidly in a recession. When managers have to retrench, it
only makes sense they will concentrate their efforts in states,
where taxes are highest and operations least efficient. So
yes, taxes matter. They matter a lot.
Now
since I read your press releases and research material, I
wish I could stand here and say that local and state taxes
in New York are as they low as they should be to make us fully
competitive. But I realize I cannot say that. What I can say
is that if you look across the country, and see how other
states are handling their fiscal issues, our pledge to try
to hold the line on tax increases clearly stands out. Just
last Friday, for example, Governor Grey Davis called for $8.3
billion in new, additional taxes in California. Keep raising
taxes Grey. Something tells me that we may be making more
announcements this year about high-tech investment in the
Hudson Valley. Tax increases also appear likely in New Jersey
and Connecticut.
But
current fiscal politics aside, there is something else that
I want to talk about that I believe is very important for
the future of New York State, and I believe holds out tremendous
promise for making us, once again, the economic engine of
the nation. I do not hide my admiration for Governor Pataki,
in part because I consider him a friend, but also because
I believe he has been a great Governor with a tremendous record
of achievement. Among all his achievements, I am convinced,
the one that is likely to have the greatest long term significance
is the fundamental realignment that he has engineered in New
York State. Under his leadership, the New York Republican
Party is now competing successfully among all groups of New
Yorkers, whatever their ethnicity. This is tremendously positive
news, because I have always believed that there is a powerful
voice within the African-American community, and also quite
clearly in the Hispanic community, for pro-growth, pro-business
economic policies.
What
we see in election results, we see even more clearly in poll
results. Quinnipiac, for example, did two polls in recent
months in New York City on attitudes about raising taxes.
Strikingly, what we find is not only that African-Americans
and Hispanics are strongly opposed to raising taxes, they
are significantly more opposed than White New Yorkers. In
one question, only 10 percent of African-Americans and only
12 percent of Hispanics said they supported a tax increase
in New York City to close the budget gap. By contrast, 25
percent of White voters said they supported a tax increase.
Why? I believe the answer is a combination of old-fashioned
common sense and rational self-interest. For all of the progress
in recent years, African-Americans and Hispanics are still
more likely to find themselves on the periphery of the job
market. And that matters, because if you are less certain
about your economic prospects, if you are only a few paychecks
ahead of your rent or your mortgage, the reality is you are
going to be much more wary about government taking money out
of your pocket. Yes, you are concerned about services. But
you are more concerned about your immediate expenses. In the
coming years, I am confident that this basic reality will
become better understood, and it will significantly change
how decisions about taxes and spending are made.
While
we focus on the budget here in Albany, and the need to maintain
fiscal discipline, I am reminded by my friends on Wall Street
that we must also pay attention to what is happening in Washington.
And unfortunately, if history is any guide, our legislators,
particularly in New York City will not be our biggest friends.
If you go back in time, you find numerous examples, of how
New York legislators have voted against our own self-interest.
In
the last session, for example, large number of New York City
representatives had zero ratings from a group called the Small
Business Survival Committee, including districts with predominantly
Hispanic populations. You also see it on trade issues. Although
New York is the center of global commerce, our legislators
regularly vote against trade legislation. Last year, for example,
all New York City representatives, except one, voted against
Fast Track, which gives the President greater flexibility
in negotiating treaties with other countries. Both senators
also voted against this legislation.
It
is also the case that New York City's congressional delegation
often pursues policies that undermine Wall Street, in spite
of the obvious fact that the financial services industry provides
a huge source of government revenue. Back in the late 1980's,
for example, the New York City delegation strongly opposed
reductions in federal capital gains taxes. On a regular basis,
they fight against reducing marginal income tax rates, even
though these rates are the single biggest reason why New York
annually sends $18 billion more to Washington than we receive
back in aid. And now, we are seeing immediate and predictable
opposition to President Bush's new stimulus plan, including
criticism of the proposal to eliminate the double taxation
of dividends, which may be one of the most pro-New York pieces
of legislation in years. As Burton Malkiel wrote in the Wall
Street Journal last week, "eliminating the double taxation
of dividends would lead to a powerful rally in stock prices
and would do much to lift the penumbra of uncertainty that
has bedeviled both consumers and corporate managers." So as
we think about what is good for business, we must focus not
just on Albany, but on Washington as well.
As
I close, I want to emphasize that despite the challenges that
we currently face, we have the leadership, vision and sense
of purpose that is necessary to manage our way through these
current difficulties. And that is why I am profoundly optimistic
about our state and our nation. We are a great nation, with
an imperfect history, a noble people, but not a perfect people.
There is a lot of good in us, and we should resist the temptation
to always focus on our faults. I believe that we continue
to be a beacon of light and a symbol of hope across the world
and for all humanity. I believe, as Thomas Jefferson once
said, that we are the last, best hope of mankind, and I believe
as Ronald Reagan said, that our best days lie ahead of us.
If
we are to realize our destiny, and with humility accept it,
then we must embrace the weeks, months and years ahead with
confidence, courage, commitment and compassion. I am confident
we will.
|