Environment Committee Alert
Contact: Darren Suarez
October 25, 2011
- Hazardous Waste Regulatory Fee Changes
- Discussions with DEC
- Chapter 99 of the Laws of 2010
- Disposition of Revenue Collected by § 72-0402
- Business Council Industry-Environment Conference October 26-28
- New York ISO and ISO New England Energy and Synergy Conference
Many hazardous waste generators have expressed concern upon learning that the Department of Environmental Conservation (DEC) will be issuing two hazardous waste generation invoices during the 2011 calendar year.
The Business Council after some investigation agrees with the DEC although two invoices will be issued in 2011, that they cover separate annual periods (2010, 2011). The first invoice will be based on the average hazardous waste generated in 2007, 2008, and 2009. The billing year on that invoice will indicate “0789.” The second invoice will be based on actual amounts generated in 2010 and will cover the 2011 annual period.
Additionally, the Business Council strongly supports the DEC’s determination not to assess any fees for generators who did not generate any waste during calendar year 2010. Under some interpretations of the current law waste generators, who generated waste in 2007, 2008, or 2009 would have been assessed a few in 2010 even if they did not generate waste in 2010.
Due to a number of factors many companies were concerned about the receipt of two hazardous waste bills in one calendar. The Business Council immediately upon hearing of the concerns our members address this issues with the DEC. Here you will find a letter that the DEC drafted as a result of our numerous conversations. The Business Council believes that this letter represents a fair and accurate depiction of the current situation.
The letter explains that, “no regulated entity is being billed twice for a single annual period” and acknowledges that much of the confusion stems from a memo that was “not the model of clarity.” Specifically, the DEC Division of Management & Budget Services states memo stated that, “the new law requires a one-time transition invoice.” The new law did not require a transitional invoice, so much as it required for one year the annual invoice should be based upon an alternative means of calculation.
The DEC at the conclusion of the letter acknowledges that there is an inherit incongruity to “requiring generators who did not generate any waste during calendar year 2010 to pay an annual fee based exclusively upon activity in earlier years.”
"Accordingly, DEC has determined that any generator who did generate any hazardous waste during 2010 will not be subject to a transitional charge based merely upon waste generated in the prior three years. In other words, generators which did not create any waste during calendar year 2010 will not be assessed any fees for that year.”
As part of a financing package to address the state parks, Chapter 99 of the Laws of 2010 restructured the hazardous waste fees increasing assessments on the state’s largest hazardous waste generators, and resulting in a net reduction of assessments for others. Overall, the proposal increased assessments by 22 percent, or about $2 million, with the additional funds dedicated to the “Environmental Protection Fund.” These provisions are in S.7988/A.11308 (provisions start on page 25, line 19 of the bill text.)
Specifically, Chapter 99 of the Laws of 2010, did the following:
- Repeals existing hazardous waste program fees (Article 72-0402) and surcharges (Article 72-0403);
- Imposes a $130 per ton fee on hazardous wastes after 1/1/2010, subject to the following caps:
- $300,000 for a facility generating under 4,000 tons per year
- $400,000 for those over 4,000 TPY and at or under 10,000 TPY
- $800,000 for those over 10,000 TPY
- Imposes a new $6,000 per year assessment on generators of 15,000 TPY or more of hazardous wastewater;
- Retains existing exemptions for remedial wastes (including all cleanups under state and federal superfund) and for universal wastes;
- Generators recycling at least 90 percent of their waste or wastewater pay assessments on only the non-recycled wastes;
- Changes the methodology for calculating assessments to base the current year’s assessments on the prior year’s actual generation; and
- Directs 15 percent of these receipts to the Environmental Protection Fund to pay for non-hazardous waste expenditures (not to exceed $2.1 M).
Chapter 99 of the Laws of 2010 Does Not Contain Specific Authorization for a Transition Invoice.
Nowhere in Chapter 99 of the Laws of 2010, is there an explicit authorization for the development of a transitional invoice. Neither the bill jacket nor the legislative memo infer a transitional invoice, the legislative transcripts nor the then Governor Paterson’s press release. In addition, analysis conducted by the Division of Budget, the Legislature and the Division of Budget does not reflect substantial additional revenue derived from a transition invoice.
The DEC has stated that the authorization for the one time transition invoice result from the provision contained in § 7 of Chapter 99 of the Laws of 2010.
§ 7. Subdivision 4 of section 72-0402 of the environmental conservation law, as added by chapter 471 of the laws of 1985 and renumbered by chapter 62 of the laws of 1989, is amended to read as follows:
4. Bills issued for annual hazardous waste program fees shall be
[estimated bills]based [either: a. upon the actual activity of the preceding calendar year, as reported to the department, or as adjusted by the department to reflect non-recurring events or reporting errors, or b. in those instances where actual activity cannot be determined or where the status of a person subject to the provisions of this title has changed since the issuance of the bill for the preceding year so that a different fee category is applicable, upon estimated activity for the current calendar year, as determined by the department]upon actual hazardous waste generated for the prior calendar year, as demonstrated to the department's satisfaction. During the first year of implementation of this subdivision, bills will be based on the average quantity of hazardous waste generated for the previous three calendar years.
Subdivision 4 of § 72-0402 amends the hazardous waste program fee from an annual estimated bill based upon generated hazardous waste of the prior calendar year, or as adjusted by the department; to a bill based upon actual hazardous waste generated for the prior calendar year. Chapter 99 of the Laws of 2010 contains a provision that stipulates the years bill will be calculated in a different manner. The effective date for this section is April 1, 2010.
Annual invoices are sent by the Department to all hazardous waste generators. Payments are sent to DEC. Of the revenue collected, 15% is transferred to the Environmental Protection Fund not to exceed $2.1 million, 71% is transferred to the Hazardous Waste Remedial Fund's Industry Fee Transfer Account, and the balance is used to fund other environmental quality program needs. The Hazardous Waste Remedial Fund's Industry Fee Transfer Account is used to pay 50 percent of the debt service associated with the 1986 Environmental Quality Bond Act (EQBA) bonds used for the remedial program.
Regulatory roadblocks, and an extended general session on shale gas development, focusing upon real and practical information about developments with Marcellus Shale will take center stage at The Business Council of New York State, Inc.’s 2011 Annual Industry-Environment Conference October 26 - 28, at the Holiday Inn Saratoga Springs.
The conference will feature Nicolas Loris of the Heritage Foundation, in Washington D.C. and Pradeep Haldar of the University of Albany as they discuss Solar Energy Developments and incentives. Participants will hear remarks from Joseph Martens, Commissioner of the New York State Department of Environmental Conservation and Francis Murray, President and CEO of the New York State Energy Research and Development Authority.
Engineers attending the conference may earn up to six NYSED continuing education professional engineering credits. One and a half credits are awarded for each 90-minute session completed. A certificate is sent at the completion of the conference.
The conference will provide timely information on ever changing state environmental programs, and updates from industry experts on innovations in clean technology, energy conservation and best practices. Seminars will focus on a range of topics from climate change and recycling programs to brownfield cleanup and water infrastructure and energy efficiency investments.
New York ISO and ISO New England November 1, Energy and Synergy Conference
New York ISO and ISO New England are pleased to present this informative and engaging conference to consider the major drivers of change in today’s electric industry. Industry participants will join government officials and other policymakers to discuss the evolving role of competition and innovation in the Northeast electricity markets, with a focus on empowering consumers. Technology vendors will be on hand to describe a variety of new products and services aimed at addressing current and future challenges.